|
“If we haven't done things for
some greater good, Julia,
then we're common criminals and that's all”
Idealists
Ideals remain ever beyond our
grasp...hence the name. And yet we uphold
them: aspirations to which we may ever strive.
Should we? When does devotion to an ideal
beget an ideology? And if we cleave to it too
tenaciously, blinkered creatures that we are,
might we be doomed betray the very dream to which
we aspire?
Robert Ardrey’s Shadow of Heroes begins
here and plunges into thorny political, moral, and
even epistemological quandaries. The play
does so with dramatic flair and heartfelt passion,
showing historical movements through the lives and
relationships of human beings in all their pathos,
humor, frailty, and transcendence. The result is
not only a philosophical confrontation, but
exciting, moving, funny, and frightening theater.
Based on actual people and events, Shadow of
Heroes is an American author’s account of
the Hungarian Revolution of 1956. We begin in a
Budapest safe house in 1944, the eve of the Nazis’
defeat, as three resistance fighters plan to make
contact with their Russian liberators. The
extraordinary stories of the three—committed
Communist leader László Rajk, his wife and partner
Julia, and his deputy János Kádár—unfold as they
help to create a post-war government under Party
directives from Moscow. The twisting history sees
János, an obedient worker, ascend almost in spite
of himself to party leadership; László, whose
popularity threatens the state’s authority,
convicted of treason one year, but rehabilitated
seven years later; and Julia imprisoned, then
released, and then embraced as a martyr who
inspires the rebellion itself...as well as the
Soviet tanks that crushed it.
This fictionalized but essentially true story
celebrates idealists. Unflinchingly devoted to a
better future for all mankind, they face political
foes, one another’s mistrust, and their own crises
of faith. Their world becomes a hall of mirrors in
which personal truth is distorted beyond
recognition. Guided by an ironical but
feeling narrator in scenes that are by turns
touching, tense, and even absurdly funny (much
like Armando Iannucci’s recent film Death of
Stalin), the play’s characters include
unyielding visionaries, compromised flunkies,
self-serving Machiavels, petty bureaucrats,
sadistic enforcers, and innocent children.
What Goes Around
In 1958, Shadow of Heroes
was as urgent as it was philosophical. The story
of the Hungarian Rebellion two years before had
received less notice in American papers than the
concurrent Suez crisis, which bore more
immediately on American economic interests. Ardrey
drew attention to what he called the “Hungarian
Passion” in horrified sympathy. It is said
he may have achieved more than a stage triumph
with its London opening, which starred Peggy
Ashcroft under the direction of Peter Hall: within
two weeks, Julia Rajk and her son were released
from Soviet imprisonment. Even so, the play was
never performed on Broadway. We know of only one
New York production, in 1961 at the off-Broadway
York Playhouse, and another in Seattle in 1964.
Shadow of Heroes scrutinized the power and
mechanics of the Soviet Union under Stalin and
Khrushchev, but it is not leftover propaganda from
the Cold War. It remains current and broadly
meaningful. For those with a taste for irony:
another distraction for Americans in ‘56 was the
presidential contest, in which both Eisenhower and
Stevenson accused the Soviet premier of election
meddling. More deeply, Ardrey’s topical drama asks
complicated questions that echo in 2018. Its
concerns are the topics of headlines from a riven
and polarized America, and from nationalist
movements and autocratic states around the world.
We hear these echoes in reports of fake news,
anthem protests, church scandals, the #MeToo
movement, and innumerable state repressions and
cover-ups. The play details the many ways that
ideological zeal may corrupt its adherents.
It reveals how the self-interested may manipulate
information to protect their own power. It
exposes the anointed leaders of a faith betraying
its central tenets, even in the name of preserving
that faith’s practice. It unveils the chaos and
suspicion that infest and undo autocracies.
It shows how one person’s celebrity may be
manipulated to serve multiple political ends. It
affirms that one woman’s suffering brought to
light may ignite national change.
Provocateur
Ardrey’s work always closely engages
the complexities of human social and political
behavior. Indeed, to many, he is better known for
his controversial anthropological nonfiction, such
as The Territorial Imperative (1970).
But, author of numerous screenplays as well,
including the Oscar-nominated Khartoum, he
was at heart a dramatist, gifted in bringing his
inquiries to life. His closest companions in our
theatrical tradition might be Tom Stoppard or
Bertolt Brecht. His plays range in style
from fantastical (such as Thunder Rock) to
literal (the Civil Rights play Jeb) to the
documentary Shadow of Heroes, which
recalls the Federal Theater Project plays
performed at Metropolitan: Power, One-Third
of a Nation, and Injunction Granted.
Those plays from the 1930’s were also idealistic.
In the end, we need ideals, just as we need
martyrs, to set impossible standards to guide our
paths. May we be ever mindful of our own
capacities for arrogance and frailty, as well as
for grace.
We are proud to present Shadow of Heroes, a play
that embraces the promise and danger of tenacity
with such complexity and heart, in our 27th
season, the Season of Perseverance.
|